Is enamel cookware safe?

You have probably done what most people do. Stood over a pan, seen a scratch in the black coating, and wondered whether the egg you are about to cook is now carrying a little of that coating into your child's plate.

That worry is not silly. It is the reason a lot of Indian kitchens moved away from non-stick in the first place, and the reason enamel looks appealing until you start wondering what the glaze itself is made of.

Yes, enamel cookware is safe, with one condition: the enamel has to be intact. No chip that exposes the metal underneath. A scratch on the surface is a scratch. A chip is a different thing, and that piece should stop cooking.

What the surface actually is

Porcelain enamel is glass, melted onto steel. Fujihoro's enamel is applied by hand and fired repeatedly in a furnace that reaches 850°C, until the glass and the steel become one material rather than a coating sitting on top of another one.

That matters more than it sounds. A non-stick coating is cured onto a surface, and it fails from the top down: it scratches, it flakes at the edge, and once it starts lifting a spatula can catch it. Fired enamel has no edge to lift, because the glass is not on the steel, it is part of it.

What your food touches is therefore glass. Glass does not react with acid, does not react with alkali, and gives nothing back to the food. Cook tamarind in it, cook curd in it, squeeze lemon over the top of it, leave the leftovers in it overnight. The pot does not care.

The four things that actually go wrong

The material is not the risk. Handling is. Every one of these comes from the use and care guide, and every one is avoidable.

  1. An empty pot on a lit flame. Never put an empty pan on the stove, not even to preheat. Have the oil, the water or the food in it before the heat goes on. It is the first warning in the guide for a reason.
  2. Metal in the pot. Wooden, nylon or silicone. A steel spoon will eventually scratch any enamel surface, on any brand, however careful you are. Over years, that is simply what steel against glass does.
  3. Cold water on a hot pan. Let it cool first. Going from the stove straight into the sink is how enamel cracks, and a cracked pot is a finished pot.
  4. A hard knock. It is glass, so it chips if it is dropped or hit on the rim. Check the rim and the inside after any fall, and if you can see metal, retire that piece.

Three more are worth knowing. Do not fill the pan past about two-thirds. You want room for the boil. Do not put it in a microwave. And use a cloth, because the handles and the knobs get properly hot.

What this means for an Indian kitchen specifically

Most of what we cook is acidic. Tomato, tamarind, curd, lemon, vinegar, and the long slow cooking that concentrates all of them. That is exactly the kind of cooking that punishes a reactive surface, and the kind of cooking a coated pan quietly gives up on after a year of that.

Enamel was never a modern invention looking for a problem. It was the answer to that problem before non-stick existed, and it is still the answer for anyone who cooks khatti dal twice a week.

How to judge any enamel pan before you buy it

You cannot see enamel quality in a photograph, and a shop page will not tell you. Three things you can check in person, or in a listing, if you know what to look for.

The edge of the rim A clean, even lip with no thin or missing patches. Thin spots are where chipping starts, and no photograph will show you one.
How it feels in the hand Steel-bodied enamel is lighter than cast iron for the same capacity, and comes up to heat faster. Heavier is not automatically better; it is often just heavier.
Whether the maker tells you how to care for it A brand that publishes care instructions, in writing, is a brand that expects the thing to last. A brand that says nothing is telling you something too.

Enamel, or a coated pan?

They fail differently, and which failure you can live with is the whole decision.

A coated pan is easier for the first year. Eggs slide, cleaning is quick, and it asks nothing of you. Then the coating starts to go, and there is no repair: you replace the pan.

Enamel is less forgiving on day one. You will need oil. Your dosa will stick until you learn the pan. But the surface you are cooking on in year five is the same surface you cooked on in week one, and if you have kept metal out of it, it will still look like it.

If the thing you are trying to avoid is a coating that breaks down into your food, enamel is a genuinely different answer to the same question.

Who makes it, and since when

Fujihoro has made porcelain enamel on steel cookware since 1947, in Japan, and it has been sold in India since September 2014 through the exclusive importer, Global Intent. Every piece in the range is made the same way.

If you want to see what that looks like across a whole kitchen, start with our pots and pans, or our casseroles. And read the care guide before the first meal. It is short, and it is the entire difference between a pot that lasts and one that does not.

Quick answers

Is it safe if the enamel is scratched? A scratch from a wooden or nylon spoon is cosmetic. A chip that exposes the metal underneath is not, and you should stop cooking in that piece.

Does enamel put anything into the food? The surface your food touches is glass, so it stays inert and gives nothing back. Our care guide says the same thing in fewer words.

Is it all right for tomato, tamarind, curd and lemon? Yes, and this is the case for it. Those are the ingredients that punish a reactive surface, and glass is not reactive.

Does it work on induction and gas? Both. This range is carbon steel with a fired enamel surface, and it is specified for both.

Can children eat food cooked in it? The same answer as for anyone else: intact enamel, normal cooking, nothing heated empty.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.